Simnel Cake

Simnel Cake

Simnel Cake – a traditional fruit cake topped with a layer of marzipan and 11 marzipan balls. Find the recipe below.

The countdown to Easter

It’s not like me to post a recipe at 9 o’clock on a Sunday evening. Normally I’d be wrapped up in a blanket on the sofa by now, but today has been busy.

For the last week I’ve been very, very poorly and for the first time in days I’ve had enough energy to do something other than lay on the sofa dozing in and out of sleep. After a morning of shopping I locked myself in the kitchen baking hot cross buns, a simnel cake and then my new favourite mac and cheese recipe. Having made so much progress in the kitchen I wanted to make sure I shared some of it with you guys before it was too later!

Now Easter is a BIG deal in my house, and I mean BIG. A week before the big day, my Mum pulls out her Jesus Christ Superstar CD and we listen to it on repeat over and over and over again. Weirdly, when I moved out I found that I too felt the need to listen to it over again in the run up to Easter weekend.

We keep Easter very traditional in my family, although we still give each other Easter eggs we also go to church, roast a leg of lamb and decorate the house with bunches of bright yellow daffodils! It’s a real celebration.

Traditional Simnel Cake topped with 11 marzipan balls from Supper in the Suburbs

Traditional Simnel Cake

It would seem that some of the older traditions are slowly slipping away. Every year my Mum, Nan and aunties complain about a lack of Simnel Cake in the supermarket and that when they do find them they are really expensive.

After a lot of research, looking over family recipes and one or two from the internet I decided it really wouldn’t be all that difficult to make my own and so I posted this recipe back in 2012 after baking the cake for the first time.

I’ve made a few changes since then and thought it was about time I took a couple of new photos too (scroll to the end to see my original photos!). Although I’ve made the odd tweak I can promise you that it’s still a very traditional recipe, complete with 11 marzipan balls to represent each of the disciples (minus Judas of course…)

Simnel Cake is a traditional fruit cake topped with marzipan and served at Easter find the recipe on Supper in the Suburbs

The Recipe

Traditional Simnel Cake is always topped with 11 marzipan balls find out how to make it at Supper in the Suburbs

Simnel Cake

Simnel Cake is a classic British treat enjoyed around Easter. Find out how to make it here.
No ratings yet
Prep Time 45 mins
Cook Time 1 hr 45 mins
Total Time 2 hrs 30 mins
Course Dessert
Cuisine British
Servings 12 portions
Calories 509.59 kcal



  • Pre-heat your oven to gas mark 3 and weigh out all of your ingredients.
  • Cream together the butter and sugar, then add the eggs beating well.
  • Fold in the flour followed by the fruits, mixed peel, nuts and spices.
  • Once the ingredients are well combined, roll out your marzipan to roughly 2-3mm thin. Cut out a piece of marzipan the same size as the base of your cake tin.
  • Roll the marzipan back into a ball and repeat.
  • Place the remaining marzipan to one side to make into 11 equal sized balls later.
  • Then leave the extra for making your 11 balls.
  • Place a circle of greaseproof in the bottom of the cake tin and grease the sides.
  • Pour in half of the mixture then place one of the marzipan circles on top.
  • Spoon over the rest of the mix and level it with a spatula.
  • Bake in the oven for 1 hour and 45 mins or until golden.
  • When cooked leave in the cake tin to cool before turning it out onto your cake plate.
  • Brush the top of the cake with athe jam and lay the marzipan over the top.
  • Roll the 11 balls and using a little extra jam stick to the top of the cake.
  • Finally either using a blow torch or by placing the cake under a grill, toast the marzipan until it is golden brown.


Serving: 12gCalories: 509.59kcalCarbohydrates: 67.88gProtein: 8.7gFat: 24.39gSaturated Fat: 8.91gTrans Fat: 0.48gCholesterol: 72.27mgSodium: 144.44mgPotassium: 379.23mgFiber: 4.74gSugar: 46.94gVitamin A: 445.5IUVitamin C: 2.08mgCalcium: 96.61mgIron: 1.88mg
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!

Traditional Simnel Cake recipe from Supper in the Suburbs

I’ve toyed with mixing the recipe up – adding more exotic fruits, more booze, or perhaps chocolate – but I always think that if something’s not broken you shouldn’t try fixing it!

My family love this recipe and they count on it being there Easter weekend. Why not serve up a classic to your family this Easter.


Just in case you wanted a good giggle here are my original photos from 2012! Enjoy! Easter, Simnel Cake, Cake, Marzipan, Fruit cake, Baking

22 thoughts on “Simnel Cake”

  • Would you believe I only actually ate Simnel Cake for the first time last Easter. It might take me as long to progress to making my own but yours looks fab and I’m now off to look out my Jesus Christ Superstar CD!

    • It’s not Easter without Jess Christ Superstar! :-p glad I’m not to the only one with a copy 😉 have a lovely Easter Claire!

  • You’re right that it’s not so common to see this in the shops anymore, but your homemade version looks amazing, surely better than anything one could ever have bought anyway! Gorgeous!

    • Awww thanks Kavey! I definitely think homemade is always best, even if a little rustic 😉

    • Thanks Kelly 🙂 I found thr little chicks in a nest and couldn’t resist popping them on top 😀 glad you like it!

    • Thanks Sarah. I love marzipan too! Especially the golden kind 😀 I may have snaffled a (big) piece or two :-p

  • I’ve always been so intimidated by simnel cakes, but this one doesn’t seem too complicated. Going to attempt this, though it won’t look as pretty as this one does!

    • Thanks Rhiannon. I’m sure you’ll do a great job! Send me a pic on twitter when you’re done (@KitchenGoddess3 ) a good tip for getting the top piece the right size is to use the base of the pan as a template and a really sharp knife! Best of luck 🙂

  • You know, someone just mentioned simnel cake, and I realized that I wasn’t quite sure what it was. So thanks, your timing is perfect for me!

    It sounds lovely…

    (And I’m glad you’re feeling better! There has been something nasty going around, hasn’t there?)

    • Aww thanks Anne you are very sweet. Feeling much better today! I’m glad you stumbled across my post 🙂 everyone should try simnel cake at least once!

    • Haha thanks Kate :-p simnel cake and jess Christ Superstar is the perfect combo! Have a fantastic Easter!!!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.